Exploring the Nantucket Island Living: One Neighborhood at a Time

When it comes to real estate on Nantucket, no two neighborhoods are alike. From the historic cobblestone streets of Town to the quiet, sunset-drenched coastline of Madaket, each part of the island offers a distinct experience—and attracts different types of buyers or renters. Whether you're looking for a seasonal escape, investment property, or full-time island life, knowing the defining characteristics of Nantucket’s top neighborhoods can help you find the perfect match.

Sconset: Storybook Charm on the East End

Siasconset—affectionately called "Sconset"—is known for its iconic rose-covered cottages, bluff walks, and tranquil atmosphere. It appeals to buyers who value peace, privacy, and an old-Nantucket aesthetic. The walkable village center and close-knit community feel make it especially attractive for retirees, artists, and second-home owners looking to disconnect.

• Lifestyle Fit: Quiet, scenic, and walkable

• Buyer Profile: Seasonal homeowners, long-term investors

• Real Estate Note: Limited inventory and high demand keep prices steady

Brant Point: Harbor Views & Walk-to-Town Convenience

Located just steps from downtown and the beach, Brant Point is one of Nantucket’s most sought-after addresses. It attracts high-end buyers who want easy access to luxury amenities, restaurants, and the ferry—all without needing a car.

• Lifestyle Fit: High walkability, coastal elegance

• Buyer Profile: Luxury buyers, vacation rental investors

• Real Estate Note: Premium price points and strong seasonal rental income

Town: Historic Heart of the Island

The Town neighborhood is the cultural and commercial hub of Nantucket. With 18th-century homes, boutiques, galleries, and gourmet restaurants, it’s perfect for those who crave convenience and year-round vibrancy.

• Lifestyle Fit: Urban-meets-island, walkable

• Buyer Profile: Young professionals, downsizers, short-term rental investors

• Real Estate Note: High demand for condos and restored historic homes
  

Madaket: West-End Solitude with Sunset Views

If you’re looking for a more remote feel, Madaket offers wide-open skies, quiet beaches, and the best sunsets on the island. It appeals to buyers who want nature, seclusion, and a relaxed pace of life.

• Lifestyle Fit: Remote, nature-filled, low-key

• Buyer Profile: Second-home seekers, remote workers, sunset lovers

• Real Estate Note: Smaller inventory, good long-term appreciation
  
  

Cisco, Surfside & Polpis: Lifestyle-Driven Living

These neighborhoods offer a middle ground between Town and the more remote areas.

• Cisco is known for its surf-friendly beach, Cisco Brewers, and food-centric lifestyle.

• Surfside offers spacious lots, family-friendly beaches, and strong rental appeal.

• Polpis is ideal for those who prioritize privacy, with larger estates and access to trails and the harbor.

Price Trends & Investment Highlights:

• Cisco & Surfside: Median prices range from $2.5M–$4M; high seasonal demand makes them popular with short-term rental investors.

• Polpis: Tends to attract luxury buyers seeking privacy, with properties often exceeding $5M. Inventory is limited, and long-term value is strong.

Hidden Gems: Surfside’s inland streets offer better value with potential for expansion. Polpis, while higher in price, has untapped appeal for buyers who want privacy and land.

From the walkability of Town and Brant Point to the remote serenity of Madaket and Polpis, Nantucket's neighborhoods offer something for every lifestyle. Whether you're drawn to ocean access, historic character, or investment opportunities, understanding these local nuances is the first step to making a confident move on the island.